Поиск ответов на простые и не очень простые вопросы

Hard писал(а):

Олег, я таки считаю, что это следы пилы. Сложно объяснить свое мнение.

igmh1983 писал(а):

Вот, кстати, ни у кого под рукой нет случайно книги ""The Encyclopedia of Ancient Egyptian architecture", Dieter Arnold, 2003?
Скляров говорит, что в ней упоминается как раз "аутентичность" распилов. Другое дело, что там может как раз "шлифовка" упоминаться (я тоже сторонник этой версии). А может опять "приврал"?

Sawing Tools67 • Lauer already suspected that the close joining of limestone casing blocks could have been achieved as early as the Third Dynasty by a method of sawing with a copper blade drawn through the front edge of the joints (fig. 6.22).68 When the lower end of the joint was reached, the saw quite frequently cut into the foundation blocks, leaving a cutting line protruding an inch from the front line of the blocks. This method was certainly practiced for the casings of the Mastabat el-Fara'un (fig. 6.23) and of the pyramids of Unas and Senwosret I. We do not know the instrument that was used but suspect that it was a short, knifelike saw with a wooden handle.

Zuber confirms that the curved tool marks suggest the use of a saw, not a cable. Since the cut never exceeds a width of half a centimeter, the use of an instrument with teeth of flint set into a metal frame is ruled out.69 Sawing of softer stones was apparently not problematic and was carried out quite frequently; the sawing of harder rocks was, however, used only for special cases. The alabaster sarcophagus of Sekhemkhet (Third Dynasty) shows saw marks,70 as do the alabaster altars in the sun temple of Niuserra.71 Even harder stones could be completely cut by this method. The granite sarcophagus of Cheops72 and two others of the Fourth Dynasty (fig. 6.24)73 were definitely sawed, as were the granite portcullises of the Cheops Pyramid74 and the basalt paving blocks in the mortuary temples of Cheops75 and Niuserra.76 Also the famous triads of Mycerinus made of graywacke show traces of sawing.77
Petrie estimated that the sawing blades used for the sarcophagus of Cheops must have been 2.4 meters long. They were probably toothless and used with sand as an abrasive. The experiments by Stocks78 add to Petrie's ideas that the sawing power was not exercised so much by the saw itself as by the quartz sand. Nevertheless, the loss of metal must have been consid¬erable and the method so expensive that it could have been carried out only on royal monuments.
Unfortunately, no saws of this size have been discovered in Egypt.79 But smaller examples, especially in the form of, tomb models (and intended to be used for sawing wood), are known from the Third Dynasty on.80 Sawing stone has remained a method common in stonework from Roman times81 until today.
Building In Egypt. Chapter VI. Tools. Saw.

jey писал(а):

nd the basalt paving blocks in the mortuary temples of Cheops75 and Niuserra.

VOLTRON писал(а):

Сами же видели! Мои вопросы перенесли в раздел критика

VOLTRON писал(а):

"тем более АЮ аргументы приводит" - это я сейчас о базальтовых блоках

VOLTRON писал(а):

То есть их скрывают сочленения смежных блоков.

в полу Хуфу слишком уж много явных пропилов.

rekhmire писал(а):

1.О том, что скрывают сочленения знать невозможно
2.В ПОЛУ Хуфу мне известен ровно один надпил (точнее тесная троица надпилов), сделанный явно с целью "снять верхний слой" блока, разбитый упавшим архитравом.
А откуда дровишки про многочисленные реставрации пола Хуфу?

igmh1983 писал(а):

Вы не так поняли, Скляров не признаЁт наличие современных следов на блоках пола и никогда не признАет.